In the spring of '08, my health care plan terminated. I was 47, in reasonably good health, and the only thing I needed that year was a tooth extraction which was a few hundred bucks.
In the fall of '08, I landed a new job with a small private employer that offered health insurance. It would be a fun job- reintegrating juvenile felons back into the community. It might have been a great job but it was managed so poorly that I knew I wouldn't be able to last. I hadn't had a physical exam for 3 years so I found a new doctor recommended by my old doctor and I scheduled the appointment. I couldn't get in for 6 weeks.
While waiting for the appointment date, my new job was getting worse with each passing day. It was becoming rather obvious to me why my employer was experiencing a 75% annual turnover rate. I had one of those bosses with no real management skills who liked to verbally abuse employees in front of everyone else at the weekly staff meeting. In the spring of '09, I had a young offender "no show" at the agreed upon time and I talked his mother into returning him back to the program in return for not reporting him as an escapee. It worked but I had violated the rules. I knew the public brow beating would happen at the staff meeting in a couple days so I simply quit before the meeting.
This kind of pissed off my boss who immediately cancelled my insurance by not paying the premium. When I arrived at my scheduled appointment, I figured I'd be paying cash for it. The appointment cost 185 bucks and my new doctor ordered a 6 panel blood screen which is a fairly routine test. That test costs about 79 bucks at a private lab that I had been using so I figured the whole thing might cost me 300-400 bucks.
I arrived at the hospital lab a few days later. The blood draw took two minutes and was performed by a young phlebotamist who told me he was making 12 bucks an hour.
A few weeks later, I received the doctor's bill and the lab bill because my insurance had been cancelled. The doctors bill was 185. The blood test bill was 1102 dollars. My little physical exam had cost 1300 bucks. Wow.
I paid for the doctor's appointment. I then focused on trying to resolve the lab bill. I called my private lab and they assured me they were doing that draw and test for 79.00. (I recently had it done again and it was 114.00) I then contacted St. Lukes hospital billing department and scheduled an appointment. I explained my situation and that I would like to resolve the fee for 200-300 bucks which I assured them was a healthy premium over the going cost at my private lab. They asked me to submit an indigent form. I explained to them that I was not indigent nor would I fill out a form asking me for every personal piece of my information and history. They said they would send my request into some committee for review.
A month later, the committee refused to reduce the bill. I received an email.The bill would stand at 1102.00 dollars. If I did not pay it would go to collections. I did not pay.
Soon thereafter, I got a call from a collector demanding payment. I told her this. Why don't you sue me for the 1102 dollars and we will see if the judge agrees that 1102 dollars is a reasonable price for a simple blood test? I never heard from them again.
Since 2009, that bill has been listed on my credit report.
What was the net effect of not paying? My credit score hovered around 700. I lost a great rate on a conventional home loan in 2011 and got booted into a higher rate loan. In return, I simply paid an extra ten thousand in principal and effectively reduced the rate and thus the payoff which meant refinancing into a conforming loan at a lower rate with lower principal. I got shoved into a higher car loan rate which I paid off early. That was the only way to reduce the ill effects of higher interest because of a hostage taking health care system that has been an economic train wreck for all of us.
It's been 7 years. My credit score is now around 760. All of this because of a blood test which should have cost about 79 bucks.